Mariners face crossroads after playoff elimination delivers final 2026 humiliation

That's all, folks. The Seattle Mariners will not be playing baseball in October. Even if hope of them doing so dried up a long time ago, the reality of it finally hit home with their official elimination from the 2026 playoff race on Thursday.

The Mariners still had a shot at the outset of the day. Sort of. If they won their final four games while the Texas Rangers and Houston Astros each lost their last four, the Mariners would be in. Yet FanGraphs still had Seattle's playoff chances at 0.0 percent. Whatever fraction of a percent may have been hiding in there, the Rangers took care of it by beating the New York Mets in an afternoon finale of a three-game set.

It's doubtful that anyone's forgotten, but it's still worth throwing out reminders that this Mariners team A) had real World Series aspirations and B) was indeed projected as a World Series-caliber team. After going 0-for-49 in Fall Classic pursuits between 1977 and 2025, the franchise also had the law of averages on its side.

All that hype feels like a mean joke now. What we've all watched over the last six months is a would-be super-team crumble at every conceivable challenge. They never went more than four games over .500. Good baseball was rare. Bad baseball was a nearly everyday occurrence. It's that simple.

The Mariners have to decide how to fix this mess, and who is going to do it

This is one of six years in which the Mariners entered a new season in the wake of a playoff berth. Only the 1998 and 2026 teams answered with a losing season, and at least that '98 squad treated Seattle to a 40-40 season from Alex Rodriguez and a 56-homer season from Ken Griffey Jr.

The 2026 Mariners come with no such silver linings. Cal Raleigh, Julio Rodríguez and Josh Naylor all had the worst years of their career at the same time, and the Mariners even lost their shine as a pitching powerhouse.

The "We'll be back!" energy that was there in spades after the Mariners narrowly missed the World Series in 2025 is now faint, if it is there at all. In a vague sense, heads need to roll and problems need to be fixed. But as is usually the case with these things, it's in the specifics where things get messy.

According to Adam Jude of The Seattle Times, it is "unlikely" that Dan Wilson will be back in the manager's chair. So, that's at least one major question will need to be answered this winter. If president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto and/or general manager Justin Hollander also lose their jobs, the Mariners will be looking at more of a top-down restructuring.

The buzz is that Mariners owner John Stanton is unlikely to go that far. As much as Dipoto frustrates the hell out of Seattle fans, he's done more good than harm in his decade on the job. Further, the clash between this year's projections and this year's actual outcome makes it easier to conclude the real problem was in the day-to-day managing.

Even so, the Mariners need a new-look roster just as much as they need a new tone-setter. Sans Randy Arozarena, J.P. Crawford and Luis Castillo on the books, there should be some money to toss around in free agency. And with a solid collection of prospects and spare arms, the trade market should be the front office's oyster. Please, don't make us beg for Gunnar Henderson or Elly De La Cruz.

What the Mariners shouldn't do is where we can find common fears. Given Dipoto's past decisions to hire Scott Servais and Dan Wilson, another inexperienced manager should be out of the question. We must all cringe even harder at the possibility of whoever's calling the shots becoming too risk-averse to put serious effort into remaking the roster. None of us want a repeat of the silence that permeated throughout the 2024-25 offseason.

The only hope for 2026 as a force for good is that it will have shown the Mariners where they went wrong. There's no shortage of things to see, so any failure of perception on the team's part won't merely be inexcusable.

It will be unforgivable.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow