Whether the Seattle Mariners should want Seiya Suzuki hardly feels worth debating. His bat and glove arguably make him an upgrade over Randy Arozarena, never mind just a replacement. And besides, the Mariners have already determined to go after him in free agency.
The latest from Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times paints the Mariners' pursuit of Suzuki as ongoing, to a point where they "plan to bring him to Seattle" for a visit. But it also name-checks four other teams in the race for the star right fielder, and that's an undercount.
Suzuki has already met with the San Diego Padres, and Divish lists the San Francisco Giants, Toronto Blue Jays and Philadelphia Phillies as other suitors. Multiple recent reports have the Boston Red Sox hot on Suzuki's tail, and it would be silly to count out a reunion with the Chicago Cubs.
That's a lot of competition. More to the point, it's a lot of wealthy competition. That never bodes well for a mid-market club like the Mariners, and least of all in an offseason like this one.
Jake Bauers, Dustin May and Evan Phillips have already beaten their contract projections from MLB Trade Rumors, so it might be wise to think bigger than the four-year, $105 million contract that they projected for Suzuki. And while his market does overlap with Randy Arozarena's in theory, Arozarena and Scott Boras might as well be asking outfield-needy teams to bark up Suzuki's tree instead.
It's also fair to wonder if there could be a T-Mobile Park tax at play. The Mariners can and should sell Suzuki on this being a team worth joining. But when it comes to their home stadium, no amount of spin can cover up that it's one of the worst parks in baseball for hitters.
The Mariners' Seiya Suzuki chase will come down to what John Stanton is willing to stomach
The bright side of all this is that even an inflated contract for Suzuki shouldn't be out of Seattle's price range.
Yesterday's trade for Maikel Garcia was a big one, but also close to cash-neutral as far as 2027 salaries. RosterResource has the Mariners' payroll for next year at $145 million. That's down from a year-end payroll of $164 million for 2026, and well short of the club's apparent target of $175-180 million. And with Garcia joining Cal Raleigh, Julio Rodríguez and Colt Emerson among core players signed to club-friendly long-term deals, the Mariners' future has an element of safety that other clubs only wish they could have.
Back-to-back games with a homer for Seiya Suzuki! pic.twitter.com/ci231RKDfi
— MLB (@MLB) July 9, 2026
What would an inflated contract for Suzuki look like? Well, if we're assuming he can do better than MLBTR's four-year, $105 million projection, probably something more like five years and $120-130 million. If so, we're talking the biggest free-agent splash of the John Stanton-Jerry Dipoto years.
Dipoto seems keen to keep adding after the Garcia trade, saying yesterday that, "Our position-player group is not done.” He specifically spotlighted a right-handed bat as "ideal," and made a point of wanting to get "aggressive." It's hard to look at all that and not see Suzuki as an invisible center of gravity.
As the Mariners' owner has made no secret of his disdain for spending on 30-somethings, it's getting Stanton on board with Suzuki that always figured to be the hard part. This year was technically his age-31 season, but he turned 32 in August. Even a four-year deal for Suzuki would go against Stanton's philosophy, much less a five-year deal.
Dipoto's pitch to Stanton should be that now is the time for a bigger-than-usual risk. Even sans fill-ins for Arozarena and J.P. Crawford, this team is better than it showed in 2026. And if Garcia and Suzuki are those replacements, that's a World Series-caliber team. For real this time.
So, I'd do it. I'd break the bank for Seiya Suzuki. It both can and should be done. But since I'm not John Stanton, the hope now is that this doesn't prove to be wishful thinking.
