Major League Baseball is now less than two weeks away from stopping. Just… stopping. And with Jeff Passan of ESPN writing that Randy Arozarena could be the most prominent unsigned free agent when the lockout hits, there's the obligatory question: What then if you're the Seattle Mariners?
Adam Jude and Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times reported last week that the Mariners don't plan on pursuing a reunion with Arozarena. Yes, he leaves a Silver Slugger-shaped hole in the outfield. No, Brendan Donovan isn't the best pick to fill it even in the wake of the Maikel Garcia trade. Especially after all the lower-half injuries he had in 2026, Donovan would be better used in a super-utility role. As such, a corner outfielder should still be on Jerry Dipoto's shopping list.
Also according to Jude and Divish, however, Arozarena and agent Scott Boras are angling for something like a six-year, $150 million contract. This is not insider information, but the Mariners just plain aren't going to do that. And to hear it from Passan, other teams are also "balking" at the scope of what Arozarena and Boras are asking for. As a result, the three-time All-Star may not have a new team when the collective bargaining agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. on December 1.
It's fair to be skeptical. Arozarena is, after all, a decorated star who's fresh off the finest season of his career. He also has high-profile suitors, with recent reports linking him to the Baltimore Orioles and one of their high-roller competitors in the AL East, the New York Yankees.
Even so, nobody is going to give a 31-year-old with a slowing bat, a poor glove and ties to qualifying offer penalties a six-year contract. And even with time running short, "compromise" generally isn't in Boras' lexicon. One can imagine him taking Arozarena's free agency to the other side of the lockout, whenever that might be.
The Mariners could get a Pete Alonso-style opportunity to re-sign Randy Arozarena
For the meantime, the Mariners seem to prefer Seiya Suzuki for their corner outfield need.
Whereas Arozarena's $150 million ask is outside Seattle's comfort zone, Suzuki's market is a different story so long as he stays closer to the $100 million bracket. He also offers the same sort of offensive consistency as Arozarena, but with much better defense. And besides, it's an open secret that Arozarena prefers the East Coast.
There are also draft considerations, as the Mariners stand to upgrade their standing in the 2027 draft by losing Arozarena and signing Suzuki. Per the current qualifying offer rules, they would stand to give up their third-highest pick but gain a selection after the first round if Arozarena signed with another team for over $50 million.
Yet even if all this amounts to a solid blueprint, the market doesn't necessarily have to play along. What if Suzuki doesn't want to go to Seattle? And what if the Mariners can't land a suitable alternative before the lockout? And what if Arozarena is indeed still there on the other side of the lockout?
Passan referenced Freddie Freeman as a potential post-lockout template for Arozarena, but it shouldn't surprise anyone if his free agent journey goes the way of Pete Alonso's first one two winters ago. That began with Boras dreaming of $200 million. It ended in disappointment when Alonso was forced back to the New York Mets on a two-year, $54 million contract with an opt-out.
Alonso's situation then and Arozarena's now don't make for a 1:1 comparison, but one can see how the latter could end up in a similarly disappointing spot. Teams are already not buying Boras' ask. And because of pre-lockout signings and potential limits on spending in MLB's post-lockout era, there might not be as much money to go around when baseball resumes business.
Accordingly, one can also see a scenario in which the Mariners and Arozarena need each other. It's surely not Plan A for either party right now, but an Alonso-like agreement in the range of two years, $50 million with an opt-out could make sense for both come next spring or even next summer.
It's an idea worth throwing out there, at least. It's far from a likely outcome But if ever there was a winter to expect the unexpected, it's this one.
