Back when Victor Robles was a prospect, he was hailed as a five-tool player headed to a bright future in the majors. However, while he's certainly had his moments, the harsh reality is that he has never quite fulfilled his undoubted potential. Now the Mariners are searching for his replacement and a solution might well be available in Tampa Bay, who actually offers shades of Robles.
The player in question is outfielder Jonny DeLuca, who is coming off helping the Rays advance to their third World Series appearance in franchise history. Interestingly though, as per Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon of The Athletic (subscription required), sources speaking on the condition of anonymity indicate the Rays are considering trading DeLuca. Pending what the return package would look like, one of the immediate perks is that the 28-year-old is under club control for three more seasons,
From a Mariners' perspective, Mike Petriello of MLB.com has already mentioned DeLuca as a possible fix for the team's 'atrocious' defense. There were plenty of reasons why the M's finished a disappointing 76-86 in 2026, and the defense is right up there after they finished dead last in the majors with a team Fielding Run Value of -59. (And keep in mind they weren't particularly close to the Angels, who finished 29th with a -44 Fielding Run Value.)
Jonny DeLuca's defense might be outstanding, but does he have what it takes overall to help the Mariners?
DeLuca absolutely stands out as someone who can help the Mariners defensively. He's coming off a season when he finished in the top decile for Fielding Run Value, highlighted by a stellar Range (OAA) that ranked in the 98th percentile. What's important to note is that FanGraphs rates him as a very good outfielder in all three spots, providing some of that invaluable versatility which president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto loves so much.
Jonny DeLuca makes a GREAT lunging catch for the out 😮 pic.twitter.com/tjTPPTyjnQ
— MLB (@MLB) August 11, 2026
As is often the case though, there is a catch in that DeLuca's bat doesn't come off great. Among other things, this past season he ranked in the first percentile in xwOBA, had a low walk-rate, not a ton of contact and bad contact quality. The sum total was ranking in the 52nd percentile with a decidedly average Batting Run Value.
Still, the Mariners do need someone to replace Robles, after declining his $9 million team option for the 2027 season. There's a lot of regret about how things played out, after what he showed early on by hitting .328 with a .860 OPS and 153 OPS+ over the second half of the 2024 season. However, that version of him is now seemingly long gone even when healthy, so why not consider making a trade for a player who looks like him from afar?
Of course, as mentioned earlier, any prospective deal would depend on what the Rays want in return. If they want starting pitching, then the Mariners can certainly offer this, although we would be loathe to go beyond Bryce Miller or Emerson Hancock. Alternatively, Tampa Bay can never say no to prospect depth, which is another area where the M's can offer quality talent, as long as it's not the likes of Ryan Sloan, Michael Arroyo or Lazaro Montes.
Overall, yes DeLuca's bat is a concern, but for what it's worth his career .250 batting average and .684 OPS are both actually marginally better than what Robles has produced during his 10 years in the majors. Further, Lucas is basically a cheaper and younger version of Robles, with an even better glove and more speed. Throw in his aforementioned versatility, and we'd seriously consider acquiring him to be the Mariners' fourth outfielder.
