If there are two things the Mariners were missing in 2026, leadership and home runs would both rank near to or at the top of the list. So what if we were to tell you they could get someone who has a good track record of both, with the bonus of that player having previously played in Seattle? Well, it is actually possible, but in classic M's fashion, it's not without some significant caveats.
The player in question is Carlos Santana, who spent the second half of the 2022 campaign with the Mariners and helped their surge to a first playoff appearance in 21 years. At the time, J.P. Crawford talked about how the 2019 All-Star had brought the team together and made them even closer. He hit 15 homers in 79 games and M's fans still remember his key three-run bomb in the comeback win versus the Blue Jays in the Wild Card round of the playoffs.
Now 40, Santana is at an age when it is entirely reasonable to seriously consider retirement following a 17-year Major League career highlighted by 335 home runs and 1,136 RBI. However, as per Will Sammon, Ken Rosenthal and Katie Woo of The Athletic (subscription required), the first baseman has said he wants to keep playing. The question is, does he represent someone who the Mariners will want to take a flier on?
Is Carlos Santana's positive influence in the clubhouse really enough for the Mariners to bring him back?
Certainly, the Mariners would like a player who can help re-establish their long ball potency, after seeing their home run total drop from third-best in 2025 to tied-16th this past season. He's also someone who has the power to repair the clubhouse, particularly Julio Rodríguez, who still thinks fondly of him and could benefit from his return following the worst campaign of his five years in the majors.
However, as good as Santana sounds in theory, it's time for a big reality check.
Santana is coming off a season where he only played eight Major League games for the Diamondbacks, before being released in late June. He then signed a minor league deal with the Braves, but never saw any action in the big leagues and was subsequently released in mid-August. He's going to turn 41 on April 8 next year, and it's fair to question if he has anything left to give?
There's perhaps a case to be made from a financial perspective, with Santana likely to be a bargain buy one year after agreeing a $2 million deal with the Diamondbacks. However, his best days are in the rearview mirror and in truth, cult status aside, he did little else on the field other than hit home runs while wearing a Mariners uniform. It also doesn't help that he has struggled in general throughout his career whenever playing at T-Mobile Park, as evidenced by a .206 batting average and .652 OPS in 82 games,
To be clear, we're not trying to push the narrative that Santana should retire. If he wants to continue playing, then good for him and we'll cheer him on as much as anyone. However, even if he does have any gas left in the tank, the fit in Seattle just doesn't really work, no matter how much the players in the Mariners clubhouse love him.
