Mariners fans get 2 very strong hints to stop asking about an Aroldis Chapman trade

The August 3 trade deadline is only four weeks away, so the MLB news cycle is in its speculation silly season. Yet things have taken a serious turn regarding the Seattle Mariners' connection to Boston Red Sox closer Aroldis Chapman, which has basically been severed from two directions.

Take a look around, and you'll come across more than a few mentions of Chapman as a trade fit for the Mariners. Kiley McDaniel and Jeff Passan of ESPN even put Seattle at the top of their list of prospect suitors for the eight-time All-Star closer.

But don't count on it, suggests Adam Jude of The Seattle Times. As part of a bigger trade deadline preview piece that went up on Saturday, Jude wrote that the 38-year-old Chapman is "not expected to be a priority for the Mariners, at least in part because of a 'zero tolerance' stance on domestic violence."

When he was with the New York Yankees back in 2016, Chapman became the first ever player suspended under MLB's Joint Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault and Child Abuse policy. The punishment came after he was alleged to have choked his girlfriend and fired a gun inside the garage of his home in Florida. No charges were ever filed, though MLB's policy grants commissioner Rob Manfred the power to suspend players as he sees fit.

The Mariners' stance on domestic violence is unambiguously a noble one. And while the team obviously wants to win, integrity matters. If an organization is going to have a stance like that, it can't acquire a player with Chapman's history and stick to its moral code. It's one or the other, and Jude's report shows which way the Mariners are leaning.

Acquiring Aroldis Chapman from the Red Sox would be too costly for the Mariners

Even before Jude's report effectively made the Chapman concept dead on arrival, there were indications that trading for him would be too costly for the Mariners anyway.

As reported by Chris Cotillo of MassLive on Friday, a veteran scout estimated Chapman's value as being worth "two prospects, including a top-100 type and another piece." Which is wild. Baseball Trade Values estimates that the left-hander only has $3.3 million in surplus value, which hypothetically makes him worthy of only one mid-level prospect.

This is not to say that scout is off the mark. Chapman has been an ace closer for a long time, and he's done arguably his best work in his two seasons with Boston. He's also living proof that asking prices for top relievers go up during the summer, as he's previously been traded for Gleyber Torres and Cole Ragans.

Yet even if his record was squeaky clean, would the Mariners really give up a top-100 prospect plus another piece for Chapman? That's not Jerry Dipoto's style unless he sees a chance to lock in a player he really likes for multiple years. Chapman doesn't fit the bill just by virtue of being a potential free agent after 2026. And while his results are good, his velocity, strikeout rate and walk rate are all worse than they were in 2025.

Ultimately, Chapman is but one option among many for Seattle in the coming weeks. It's pretty clear that it's the others who should be in focus going forward.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow