Luke Raley's downfall has brought back a headache Mariners know all too well

This season couldn't have started much better for Luke Raley. Through April 15 he led the Mariners with a .339 batting average, 1.035 OPS and 191 wRC+. However, following a career-high four-hit performance versus the Padres, Andrés Muñoz's spectacular ninth-inning capitulation in the 7-6 loss that day was almost an omen for Raley's own collapse.

Over his next 14 games, Raley went on a horrendous run hitting just 2-for-30, and that's despite almost exclusively not being asked to face lefties. Just like that, the hottest hitter on the team turned ice cold at a time when they needed him most, with a season of such promise threatening to get away from the Mariners.

It doesn't help that Raley has also been poor defensively in right field, with Baseball Savant ranking him in the fifth percentile for Fielding Run Value. As such, it makes sense that right field is below replacement level for the Mariners, making it feel like 2025 all over again.

All of the Mariners' right field options are flawed right now

This leads to the question of where the Mariners go from here. Víctor Robles just doesn't seem like the guy who stormed onto the scene in Seattle during the second half of 2024. Meanwhile, Rob Refsnyder's roster spot could be in danger because he's struggling to hit lefties, which is the main reason he was signed in the first place.

Dominic Canzone is an option, but he really isn't a guy you want in the field, which leaves Brennen Davis as the next man up at this point. However, as much as he deserves his opportunity based on how he's been hitting the ball in Triple-A of late, this doesn't mean he's finally going to fulfil his potential years after being considered a top-rated prospect.

Another solution is to go down the route of what the Mariners did last season ahead of the trade deadline, when they acquired Josh Naylor and Eugenio Suárez to upgrade first and third base respectively. The problem with this is the market is currently projected to be light in quality right field options. One possibility is Jarren Duran, who was an All-Star just two season ago, but it's debatable how much of a clubhouse presence he can be at this point.

There's still months to go until the trade deadline, so the hope is other quality options emerge. However, this still leaves the issue of what the Mariners do in the meantime. Combine this with an injury list which keeps growing with key personnel, and the M's might have bigger priorities than right field ahead of the August 3 deadline.

Mariners shouldn't give up on Luke Raley and company just yet

From our perspective, the Mariners must hope the right field position sorts itself out. As much as Raley was never going to stay as hot as he did early on, he surely can't continue to be as bad as he's been lately. And he at least showed signs of life on Monday night versus the Braves, when his three-run homer in the bottom of the sixth started the comeback for an eventual 5-4 win.

This could be just the jolt Raley needs to get back on track. Don't forget this is still the same player who had a career year in 2024 prior to his injury issues last season. Similarly, as much as Refsnyder has struggled so far, he has a career .810 OPS versus lefties and you have to believe that version of him is still in there somewhere.

Heck, let's even throw in that Robles might be able to rediscover some of his previous magic and become a valuable depth option if he can get an injury-free run. The point is that as bad as things seem at the moment in right field, there's no reason to throw the towel in just yet.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow