Colt Emerson's latest Triple-A web gems reinforce Mariners' impossible SS dilemma

The Mariners were supposed to be a better defensive team this season, but the opposite has been true. So when Colt Emerson makes even one dandy defensive at Triple-A, it almost feels like blatant teasing. And he made three such plays on Thursday.

A pop fly down the left field line that he somehow turned into an out at second? Boom. A diving stop and throw on a ground ball up the middle? Easy. Ranging far to his right followed by a strong throw for the out? Well, that's just showing off.

These are merely the latest out of, oh, something like 1,742 examples of the 20-year-old Emerson being a gifted defensive shortstop. There might be louder tools at the position, but he plays it like he's the one who invented it.

Especially given that they're on the hook for $95 million, it's just a matter of time before the Mariners give Emerson his shot. Plays like the ones he made Thursday don't really quicken the timeline…though they do reinforce an increasingly awkward question.

How long can Mariners remain in denial that J.P. Crawford is not their best defensive shortstop?

Whenever the Mariners deem Emerson ready for The Show, he's going to play third base in deference to J.P. Crawford. And in theory, keeping the respected veteran at his natural position is obviously the right call.

In reality, though, Crawford is just not the same defender who won a Gold Glove in 2020. It's been a long time since he was, as his -35 Outs Above Average since 2022 are second-worst among shortstops. His range has diminished, and the shoulder issues he's dealt with seem to have made his already weak arm even weaker.

Put these things together, and that's how you get plays like this:

The aesthetics and teamsmanship are admirable, but does a better shortstop make that play without hitting the deck, much less having to shovel the ball to another defender?

Pondering this from the other side of a laptop might come off as a cheap shot at Crawford, but it's not like different metrics are painting different pictures of what he brings to the table defensively. There's no positive way to spin how his max throwing speed in 2026 is lower than his average in 2025. As to his range, Defensive Runs Saved also has him as subpar for four of the last five seasons.

Mind you, a rising tide lifts all boats. If the Mariners stick with their plan to put Emerson at third, Crawford will be the only deficient defender on the infield. Josh Naylor is solid at first base, while Cole Young has taken a turn toward excellent at second base.

Given how valuable the shortstop position is, though, this seemingly inevitable solution isn't so much an answer as a compromise. Nobody is rooting against Crawford, but it's hard to make the case that he's Seattle's best shortstop while Emerson is knocking on the door.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow