Skip to main content

Mariners ducked ‘exorbitant’ Gunnar Henderson asking price with Maikel Garcia trade

There was a deal to be made, but one that would have made the Orioles bite and will M's happy?
ByPaul Taylor
Sep 23, 2026; Baltimore, Maryland, USA;  Baltimore Orioles shortstop Gunnar Henderson (2) strikes out swinging during the sixth inning at Oriole Park at Camden Yards.  Mandatory Credit: Jamie LeBlanc-Imagn Images
Sep 23, 2026; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; Baltimore Orioles shortstop Gunnar Henderson (2) strikes out swinging during the sixth inning at Oriole Park at Camden Yards. Mandatory Credit: Jamie LeBlanc-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

As disappointing as the 2026 season was for the Mariners, everything which could go wrong, did. This is still a strong and talented roster overall, with Mike Petriello of MLB.com even ranking them third among all 30 teams heading into the offseason. That was before Wednesday's trade for Maikel Garcia, who's the left-side infielder they needed.

In all likelihood, the Garcia trade takes the Mariners out of the running for what might have been their riskiest possible play to fill their infield need: a trade for Gunnar Henderson.

As of November 10, Adam Jude and Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times were of the mind that the Mariners would "definitely check in" on Henderson, just because of how talented he is. In previous years, any trade inquiries involving the 25-year-old have been swiftly dismissed, and one industry source informed Jude and Divish that the asking price is "exorbitant." Still, you could make a case that the M's were in a better position than most to make the kind of offer to entice the Orioles, albeit while finding a balance which wouldn't have Jerry Dipoto feeling like he'd made a mistake.

On paper, Henderson was absolutely the type of talent who could have helped the Mariners, with his prime position being at shortstop and J.P. Crawford now all but definitely gone. Although it's worth noting the 2019 second-rounder did spend effectively half of the 2023 season playing at third base, with him going on to be named AL Rookie of the Year. Colt Emerson is considered the long-term shortstop in Seattle, but is also capable of playing at the hot corner. There conceivably could have been a situation where he and Henderson interchanged at the two positions.

A Mariners trade for Gunnar Henderson would have hit harder than what they gave up for Maikel Garcia

To get Garcia from the Royals, the Mariners gave up Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and Jose A. Ferrer. Those are three usable and talented major league pitchers, and each comes with multiple years of club control. Yet each was also non-essential, especially with Miller now two years removed from his first and only season as an above-average starter. To sacrifice the three of them for at least four years of Garcia's All-Star and Gold Glove-winning talent is more than a fair trade.

To get Henderson from Baltimore, on the other hand, would have required something more drastic.

The Mariners and Orioles organizations do have some recent familiarity with each other as a result of the Taylor Ward trade which took place back in August. Irrespective, the two teams lined up as a good match for each other when it comes to Henderson. The Orioles could use some quality starting pitching after finishing the 2026 campaign ranked 17th in team ERA, and the M's began the offseason with a surplus at the position.

The Mariners also have a longstanding strong farm system at their disposal, with MLB Pipeline ranking them ninth back in August. Yes, the Orioles were ranked slightly higher at No. 7, but should still be on the lookout to further strengthen their prospect personnel. Given this and their need for pitching, they could have looked to extract more than non-essential parts from Seattle.

With this in mind, the following trade had been on our minds:

The thinking was to effectively sell high on Emerson Hancock, coming off easily his best season, but also still arguably with the lowest ceiling out of the Mariners' current rotation options. Selling high was also the case with Felnin Celesten, who's proving to be a tremendous talent, but is also looking up at Emerson. As for Luke Stevenson, he's more solid than a future star, but as a catcher was still needed more in Baltimore than Seattle.

We felt quite comfortable with the trade put forward, but where things would have had you nervously pulling at your collar, is if the Orioles asked for George Kirby instead of Hancock. In this scenario, as far as we're concerned the prospect price would have had to go down. Either way, there's no way we were listening if the O's start asking for Bryan Woo, Kade Anderson or Ryan Sloan.

Orioles not quite as well-placed as claimed to demand the world for Gunnar Henderson

We appreciate the Orioles asking for Woo, Anderson or Sloan alludes back to the earlier report that their perceived asking price for Henderson is exorbitant. However, we don't actually believe they're in as strong a position as what's being suggested, even allowing for the absurd price the Red Sox paid to land O's franchise catcher Adley Rutschman back in August.

As noted by Jude and Divish, Baltimore has failed to capitalize on a nucleus of players now reaching arbitration eligibility. In this respect, the Orioles only have two more years of club control with Henderson. He's also represented by super-agent Scott Boras, and previous long-term extension offers by the O's have been turned down, ominously alluding to wanting to just get to free agency. The point being, that it might be a good idea to look at getting something decent for Henderson while they still can.

Further advancing the argument that the Orioles aren't quite as well-placed as they think they are to demand the world, is Henderson's form in recent years. He announced himself as a legit star in 2024, when he posted a 8.8 bWAR and finished the campaign fourth in AL MVP voting. Since then however, he's taken a couple of steps back and this past season had career-lows of a .225 batting average and .712 OPS. This is not to suggest he's a depreciating asset, but his decline in productivity does still have to be taken into account.

Ultimately, the Mariners may have always been unlikely to meet the Orioles' asking price for Henderson, especially given their normal approach to building the roster. If this ship has now sailed after the Mariners' trade for Garcia, that is arguably more of a problem for a Baltimore team that still has a Boras problem. The way he's been handling Henderson's contract situation thus far, the O's could have to come down from their exorbitant asking price to facilitate a trade.

Add us as a preferred source on Google