Skip to main content

White Sox cement Mariners' trade win by dumping Luis Castillo like a bad habit

The Rockies? Ouch.
ByZachary Rymer
Mandatory Credit: Thomas Shea-Imagn Images
Mandatory Credit: Thomas Shea-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

It was a bittersweet day when the Seattle Mariners traded Luis Castillo in July. The relationship had run its course and it was time for him to go. But, hey, at least they had the courtesy to send Castillo to a playoff contender in their deal with the Chicago White Sox. He deserved as much.

As if that trade didn't already look enough like a win for the Mariners, there's just one three-letter word to describe the latest development with "La Piedra" and the White Sox: Oof.

A trade to the Colorado Rockies? That's cold, man. Certainly no way to put a three-time All-Star like Castillo out to pasture. That's the kind of trade (this one was first reported by ESPN's Jeff Passan) you make when all you care about is disappearing a guy, so long as his salary disappears with him.

The Rockies are taking on the last $22.5 million left on the five-year, $108 million contract that Castillo signed with the Mariners in 2022. That's how badly they needed pitching. More to the point, it's how badly they wanted to also get Davis Martin from Chicago. Both he and Castillo figure to go straight to the top of the Rockies' rotation, though one hesitates to call it an "upgrade" for either hurler. And least of all for Castillo.

When Mariners fans got to know him in 2022 and 2023, Castillo was an elite fastballer who could overpower anyone. Nowadays, he has a merely average fastball and was, well, about as bad in 2026 as his 5.85 ERA would suggest. His strikeout rate was in the 26th percentile and his exit velocity was in the 17th percentile.

The White Sox knew all this, and yet they chose to send Castillo to Coors Field anyway. That's, uh, not going to go well. Everyone knows about the thin air, but the actual effect that Coors Field is so much more sinister. It's a bad place for pitchers to chase strikeouts. And no park renders pitchers more prone to hits of all stripes, but especially to doubles and triples.

Basically, the exact opposite of T-Mobile Park. And considering Castillo had a 5.04 ERA even in Seattle this year… yeah, not great.

Mariners getting out from under Luis Castillo's contract feels even more like a blessing now

Even as it became clear early on in 2026 that Castillo had to go, actually trading him never felt like an especially easy task. It's not easy to find takers for bad pitchers. It's even harder to find takers for bad pitchers making over $20 million. You can't be looking around for partners so much as marks, and those are hard to find in an era of egghead-ified front offices.

So, the mood around here was genuine shock when the Mariners not only found a taker for Castillo, but somehow dumped his entire contract on the White Sox while also extracting a usable reliever in Seranthony Domínguez and a legit prospect in Boston Smith. Even if Smith's star faded a bit in the Arizona Fall League, his breakout was still one of the more unexpected stories of 2026.

Whatever the White Sox were expecting, it was no surprise in the Pacific Northwest when buyer's remorse set in just a few weeks later. Chris Getz even had Richie Tenenbaum energy at one point, lamenting how an obviously declining pitcher was somehow getting even worse.

“The quality of pitches have definitely gone in the wrong direction,” Getz said in September. “We’ve got to solve it. We do. We’re continuing to look at some of the trends and the changes that have happened [since he left the Mariners]. It has been surprising.”

It was shortly after this that Castillo got demoted from Chicago's rotation to its bullpen. Not long after that, he was on the injured list with a right shoulder impingement. And now, he's been banished to hell on earth for pitchers.

It's not what we would have chosen for Castillo. But then again, he's not the Mariners' problem anymore, and hasn't been for a while.

Add us as a preferred source on Google