The dirt on the 2026 season's grave was still fresh when the Seattle Mariners struck for their first move of the offseason in October, using a waiver claim to pluck Michael Toglia from the Cincinnati Reds. It was interesting because he's a Gig Harbor guy who hit 25 home runs for the Colorado Rockies in 2024. It didn't cross our minds that he might be the next Jake Bauers, but that's on us.
After all, Mike Petriello of MLB.com was able to spot some similarities between Toglia and the reigning NLCS MVP, who just signed a four-year, $58 million contract with the Boston Red Sox.
That is, at least to the extent that Toglia has a similar profile to the pre-breakout Bauers. The numbers haven't been there for the 28-year-old Toglia, but he has a Bauers sort of look to him because of his plate discipline, bat speed and propensity for barreling the ball. Skills like those tend to map onto some of MLB's better hitters, so… maybe Toglia is better than his career 74 OPS+?
Digging aroung in Michael Toglia's numbers for reasons to be optimistic
Just so we're all clear: Expectations for Toglia in a Mariners uniform should be kept nice and low.
Even if he's on the 40-man roster, he'll be on the outside looking in at the 26-man roster whenever spring training begins next year. He's primarily a first baseman, and thus looking up at Josh Naylor. And while he can play the outfield, that's where he suffered the right shoulder dislocation that required season-ending surgery in August.
Otherwise, Toglia has taken 1,094 plate appearances in the majors and struck out in 385 of them. That's a 35.2 K%, and the company he keeps there only reinforces his likely non-viability as a major league hitter. The two guys on either side of him on the K% leaderboard for 2022-26 are Patrick Wisdom and Gabriel Arias.
Wisdom gets a shoutout in Petriello's piece, namely for being the one guy at the Triple-A level who had a higher expected slugging percentage (.612) than Toglia (.527) among hitters with at least 250 plate appearances. With all respect to "Patty Wise," Mariners fans know all too well that his Triple-A mashing did not translate to the majors this year. The Mariners outrighted him earlier this month.
Toglia said me next 👋 pic.twitter.com/hs7hQyd24l
— Louisville Bats (@LouisvilleBats) May 14, 2026
Still, it's notable that Toglia had a .920 OPS to show for 97 games with Triple-A Louisville in 2026. Even if that's close to the career .930 OPS he has at the Triple-A level, his prior damage all happened over 5,000 feet above sea level in Albuquerque. Louisville isn't even 500 feet above sea level.
And speaking of xSLG, it's worth splitting the switch-hitting Toglia's Triple-A performances into two sides:
Year | LH xSLG | RH xSLG |
|---|---|---|
2022 | .591 | .476 |
2023 | .458 | .329 |
2024 | .376 | .395 |
2025 | .439 | .491 |
2026 | .525 | .535 |
Over .500 from both sides of the plate? That's interesting. And it largely reflects what was going on with Toglia's barrel rate. For the first time in five tries at the Triple-A level, Toglia's barrel rate was over 15.0 percent from both sides of the plate. The league-wide norm at Triple-A this year was 6.1 percent.
Petriello noted some changes to Toglia's stance, which was deeper in the box and more open than it had been in the past. And even for him, the 24.8 chase percentage he had in Triple-A this year was an improvement.
Further, he may have finally solved the four-seam fastball. Both in the minors and the majors between 2022 and 2025, his xSLG against four-seamers was in the .400s. At Triple-A this year, he had a whopping .732 xSLG against four-seamers.
That all of this helped earn Toglia his shot with the Reds is the good news. That it lasted just 10 games before he hurt his shoulder is, obviously, the bad news. Toglia didn't get enough runway to show he was a changed hitter, as he was just 3-for-26 with 12 strikeouts in those 10 games.
So, is it with the Mariners that Toglia is finally going to have his Bauers-ian Cinderella story? It's best not to count on it. There's just way too much swing-and-miss here for comfort. And even if he gets that fixed, he's not exactly looking at a clean path to a roster spot.
But if nothing else, consider all this an excuse to keep an eye on him when they're finally playing ball next year.
