Skip to main content

The Maikel Garcia trade was Mariners wisely admitting defeat on Jose A. Ferrer

Probably for the best.
ByZachary Rymer
Mandatory Credit: Dennis Lee-Imagn Images
Mandatory Credit: Dennis Lee-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

It wasn't even a year ago that the Seattle Mariners traded for Jose A. Ferrer, and then immediately started hyping him as absolutely being worth the top-100 prospect they gave up. Harry Ford would be missed, sure, but Jerry Dipoto was downright effusive.

"We feel like we got the No. 1 trade target on our list," Dipoto said of Ferrer. "Like, this was the guy that, if we could dream the dream, who would you want to acquire? This was the guy we were looking to acquire."

And now… [Keyser Soze poof]… he's gone. Ferrer is a Kansas City Royal, via the Maikel Garcia trade. And while Dipoto has implied he didn't want to trade the 26-year-old lefty, it's telling just how much his Ferrer framing has changed. In late 2025, he was a "No. 1 trade target." In late 2026, trading him was just the cost of doing business.

The Mariners didn't have much to lose by ending the Jose A. Ferrer experiment

To be fair, Ferrer was hardly the worst part of a Mariners bullpen that descended into uselessness as 2026 went along. If anything, you can look back at his 73 appearances and feel grateful for his presence.

It's just that the Ferrer that was promised never really showed up. We were promised an electric, strike-throwing lefty who was just an adjustment or two away from being more than the average-ish reliever he had been for the Washington Nationals. In actuality, Ferrer went from a 97 ERA+ and a 1.265 WHIP as a National to a 94 ERA+ and 1.469 WHIP as a Mariner.

The generous take on Ferrer's 2026 season is that his 96th-percentile ground ball rate was a bad fit for an extremely porous infield defense. Yet that wouldn't have been as big of a problem if Ferrer had found more swing-and-miss as a Mariner, which seemed to be the whole idea when the brass was talking up his slider and changeup as underused pitches. Instead, Ferrer leaned even more heavily on a sinker that got hit for a .297 average.

Ferrer also still couldn't solve right-handed batters, who went from an .802 OPS against him in 2025 to a .951 OPS against him this year. And even if his defense let him down, there was ultimately little daylight between his 4.17 ERA and 4.09 xERA.

This sure seems to be who Ferrer is. Pretty good for ground balls. Pretty good against lefties. Pretty good for bulk. Not at all any kind of leverage arm.

This is the Royals' problem now, whereas the Mariners' problem concerns a bullpen that was thin even before Ferrer got subtracted from it. Dipoto absolutely needs to see to it, and preferably by signing or trading for a lefty who would be a significant upgrade over Ferrer.

Thankfully, that's a low bar to clear and the Garcia trade didn't exactly reduce the budget. And like Dipoto said, at least the Mariners have gotten a Gold Glove third baseman out of it in the meantime.

Add us as a preferred source on Google