Skip to main content

Tai Peete’s electric rise makes Peoria Javelinas’ AFL title feel like a Mariners loss

Good for him. Bad for the M's.
ByZachary Rymer
Springfield Cardinals' Tai Peete takes an at-bat against the Amarillo Sod Poodles in Game two of the Texas League Championship series in Springfield, Missouri on Tuesday, Sept. 22.
Springfield Cardinals' Tai Peete takes an at-bat against the Amarillo Sod Poodles in Game two of the Texas League Championship series in Springfield, Missouri on Tuesday, Sept. 22. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

The Seattle Mariners' season ended about six weeks ago, but they're not done taking losses in 2026. The Arizona Fall League just wrapped up, and the prospects who were there to represent the Seattle Mariners on the Peoria Javelinas didn't do much to boost the club to the AFL championship with an 8-3 win over the Surprise Saguaros on Saturday.

Former Mariners prospect Tai Peete, on the other hand, was the darling of both the Javelinas and arguably the AFL as a whole.

Now with the St. Louis Cardinals via the Brendan Donovan trade, Peete used the AFL to put an exclamation mark at the end of a breakout year. In 66 minor league games, he had a .908 OPS. In 19 AFL games, he upped the ante with a 1.103 OPS, 13 extra-base hits and 20 stolen bases. He was named the Offensive Player of the Year for the AFL.

The eight current Mariners prospects who were in the AFL might as well be headed home empty-handed. Boston Smith and Brandon Eike each finished with an OPS in the .600s. And while Adam Smith got a nice write-up in The Athletic, it came across as a thinly veiled excuse for Keith Law to make puns related to the 18th century economist. Smith had a 5.40 ERA in seven AFL appearances, which was the lowest ERA among five Seattle pitching prospects.

At least Matthew Ellis had a decent time, getting into 14 games and homering three times with 14 runs batted in… yet he also struck out 22 times to rank third on the Javelinas, and he didn't see any action in the championship game.

Tai Peete seems determined to turn the Brendan Donovan trade into a W for the Cardinals

Turning back to Peete, his stock fell so hard and so fast after the Mariners made him the No. 30 pick in the 2023 draft that he was basically a throw-in when they acquired Donovan from the Cardinals. Cut to now, and it feels like an outrage that he's only their No. 17 prospect for MLB Pipeline.

The speed, power and arm strength have always been there for Peete, but his hit tool got exposed as a potentially fatal flaw in his first three professional seasons. That changed this year, most notably to the extent that he cut his strikeout rate as the year went along. He fanned 17 times in 93 plate appearances in the AFL, a respectable 18.3 K%.

After having made it to Double-A even before the AFL season kicked off, Peete is in line to potentially make his major league debut in 2027. If anything, it wouldn't be surprising if he arrived in St. Louis before Jurrangelo Cijntje, who was supposed to be the Cardinals' big prize in the Donovan trade.

We only wish could put a positive spin on Donovan's immediate future with the Mariners. Injuries turned 2026 into a lost season for the 2025 All-Star. And while his bat remains an asset, where he's supposed to play in the field is a question without a good answer. And the Mariners probably couldn't trade him even if they wanted to. This year crushed Donovan's trade value, and he's otherwise in the same hard-to-trade boat as other pending post-2027 free agents.

To be clear, nobody is calling the Donovan trade a loss for the Mariners just yet. It's just hard to ignore that it's trending that way, especially with how fast Peete is rising.

Add us as a preferred source on Google