Skip to main content

MLB Network insider's Brendan Donovan trade take clashes with Mariners' reality

A trade? Now? Nah.
ByZachary Rymer
Mandatory Credit: Steven Bisig-Imagn Images
Mandatory Credit: Steven Bisig-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Coming into the winter, you didn't need to tell us that Brendan Donovan represented an awkward roster fit for the Seattle Mariners. He was ill-cast as a starting third baseman in 2026, and he probably shouldn't be on the grass full-time either. There was thus some sense in speculating about a trade… but not so much anymore.

With Maikel Garcia set to man the hot corner for at least the next four years, this year's experiment with Donovan at the hot corner is mercifully over. The plan now, as Jerry Dipoto outlined for Brady Farkas of Roundtable Sports, is for Donovan to go back to the super-utility role in which he made a name for himself in St. Louis.

Granted, this may be aspirational as long as the Mariners lack a replacement for Randy Arozarena in left field. Unless they hold onto Luke Raley (which seems unlikely), left field would figure to be the center of gravity for Donovan's playing time moving forward.

This doesn't seem to be Plan A, though. As Dipoto also said after the Garcia trade, the "position-player group is not done," and on the shopping list is a right-handed hitter who can play the outfield. If Dipoto can find that guy, the other need on the position player side can take care of itself: “We’ll need to add some type of versatile defender who can give those guys a day off on the infield."

Brendan Donovan. You're talking about Brendan Donovan. Even if he's not a good third baseman, he can play there, second base and even shortstop and first base as needed. Given that he has a Gold Glove and an All-Star nod in his history, it's a role that Donovan is somewhat overqualified for. But at the same time, it's a sign of a good roster if Donovan is coming off your bench and doing a Ben Zobrist act day in and day out.

Now would be a very weird time for the Mariners to trade Brendan Donovan

All this is to say that, following the Garcia deal, a trade of Donovan went from being only sort of on our minds to pretty much not there at all. At least, that is, until Jon Morosi of MLB Network went on "Wyman and Bob" and floated the idea.

"I'm talking myself more and more into saying that Donovan might have a difficult roster fit with this team," Morosi said. "To where you might even see -- again, it may be asking a lot -- you might even see a move of Donovan for a similar arbitration lane player this week ahead of the tender deadline, which is Friday."

This doesn't sound like reporting. It sounds more like riffing. And in all fairness, that happens. Live broadcasting in all its forms is really hard, folks. Don't laugh. That's a serious take.

What Morosi's take is not is especially logical, and for reasons that go beyond what we laid out above. It's bad enough that Donovan's lost 2026 season helped tank the Mariners' contention outlook. It's worse that it also tanked his trade value. There surely isn't much demand for a player who only played in 39 games this past season. And while Donovan isn't expensive, his $6.1 million projected salary isn't cheap either. Next year is also his last before free agency.

As Morosi alluded to, maybe there's a trade in which Donovan gets swapped for an upgrade sort of player for whom 2027 will also be his last dance before free agency. Steven Kwan, for example. But once you get into possibilities like that, you're also adding prospects to the deal, and then having to turn around and find another guy who could be the utility guy that Donovan was slated to be.

All of it just doesn't add up to a likely trade scenario, much less one that could go down before today's non-tender deadline.

Add us as a preferred source on Google