There's an awful lot of smoke about the Seattle Mariners finally moving a starting pitcher in an offseason trade. Just don't expect it to be Logan Gilbert or Ryan Sloan, which makes it that much easier to guess who can be had. It's likely George Kirby, Emerson Hancock, Bryce Miller or bust.
FanSided's Robert Murray did a Reddit AMA on Friday in which he was asked what he's been hearing on the Mariners. The bad news? He doesn't expect them to score Seiya Suzuki or Ian Happ. The good news? Well, depending on your definition, he also doesn't expect them to trade Gilbert.
A Gilbert is a fascinating idea, but ultimately makes little sense based on his status as a pending free agent with a relatively lofty salary. And because of the looming lockout, the thinking around MLB is that pending free agents might only get moved for each other. Something like, say, a Gilbert-for-Steven Kwan trade would be a hard sell.
So, you can knock at least one name off the list of eight starters that Jerry Dipoto perceives the club as having lined up for the 2027 season. The other that can go is top prospect Ryan Sloan, who Justin Hollander all but confirmed is "untouchable" during the GM Meetings.
Given that he's an even higher-rated prospect and slated to pitch out of the rotation next season, Kade Anderson is presumably just as untouchable as Sloan. It's otherwise no surprise that Bryan Woo's name hasn't come up. With three seasons of club control left, the Mariners would be mad to sell low on him after 2026 while they know from 2025 that he still has Cy Young-caliber upside.
Logan Evans, meanwhile, is still recovering from Tommy John surgery. He's in play to make an impact in 2027, but he's certainly the No. 8 guy on the depth chart that Dipoto alluded to.
Mariners might have to limit their ambitions if they're only willing to trade one of 3 starting pitchers
And thus, we have ESPN's Alden Gonzalez specifically labeling Kirby, Hancock and Miller as the "more attainable" trade chips among Seattle's starters.
Each of those three names comes with pretty much the same elevator pitch: multiple remaining years of club control and some history of production worthy of a top-of-the-rotation starter. Kirby was an All-Star in 2023. Miller led Mariners pitchers in rWAR in 2024. Hancock broke out this year and ran a 3.57 ERA over 25 starts.
Each also comes with a catch, however. Kirby and Miller have dealt with injuries and diminishing returns over the last two years. Hancock was a bust before 2026, and various ERA estimators are chilly on the sustainability of his breakout. It's thus no surprise to go to Baseball Trade Values and see relatively muted figures for each pitcher's surplus value:
Player | Age | Years of Control | Surplus Value |
|---|---|---|---|
George Kirby | 28 | 2 | $34.1M |
Emerson Hancock | 27 | 4 | $23.1M |
Bryce Miller | 28 | 3 | $20.6M |
To put these figures in context, let's think of a hypothetical trade with the Baltimore Orioles for Gunnar Henderson. His surplus value is calculated at $50.3 million, meaning none of these three is going to get him back in a one-for-one swap. The Mariners would also have to add on prospect talent.
And that's just if the Orioles were being reasonable. To hear it from Adam Jude and Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times, their perceived asking price for Henderson is "exorbitant." It's reasonable to ask if an offer headlined by any of those three starters even gets a foot in the door for Henderson.
This is for a guy who, though obviously talented, is likewise sliding down a hill of diminished returns and who only has two years of club control left. It's enough to make you wonder how high the asking prices go for some of the hotter, more controllable bats on the Mariners' radar. Per Jude, these include Otto Lopez, Zach Neto and, yes, Elly De La Cruz. Does it take a Woo to get invited to those parties? A Sloan? Heck, an Anderson?
If so, whether those guys should be on the table is a fair question. From where we're sitting, giving up any of the three for Lopez or Neto would be tough. But for De La Cruz? Heck yes. Let's talk, Cincinnati Reds.
But if it must be that Kirby, Hancock and Miller are the only starters the Mariners are willing to part with, it's probably best to adjust expectations downward. In all likelihood, those guys aren't bringing back a Henderson so much as a Jordan Westburg. Or a Matt Shaw, if the Chicago Cubs want in on this conversation.
Hey, every little bit helps. But knowing how much help the Mariners need this winter, it feels unwise to be closing doors.
