Mariners shouldn't waste time on respected former veteran who just came available

The Seattle Mariners should avoid wasting time and resources on a waiver claim for Carlos Santana. While Santana is a familiar face who once provided valuable veteran leadership in Seattle, the reality is that his current production and hefty salary make him a poor fit for this team’s needs.

As Santana was placed on outright waivers by the Cleveland Guardians, any team claiming him would be responsible for the remainder of his $12 million contract. For a player slashing just .225/.316/.333 with only 11 home runs, that’s simply too steep a price to pay.

Mariners have no reason to pursue a reunion with Carlos Santana

The Mariners already have a logjam when it comes to veterans at first base. Donovan Solano, who has largely been pushed to the bench despite his utility and experience, is essentially filling the same role Santana would occupy.

The front office’s unwillingness to deploy Solano regularly speaks volumes, signaling that Seattle is prioritizing upside and production over clubhouse vibes. If Solano isn’t being utilized in tandem with first base starter Josh Naylor despite his track record, it makes little sense to bring in another aging, light-hitting first baseman with nearly identical limitations.

This isn’t to dismiss Santana’s leadership or the intangible energy he brings to a roster. Mariners fans have fond memories of his contributions during his short stint in Seattle, and the idea of a reunion may tug at some nostalgic heartstrings.

But the hard truth is that rosters aren’t built on vibes alone, and this team is in the thick of a playoff chase where every roster spot and every dollar matters. Committing significant financial resources to a player who offers little offensive upside would only serve as a distraction and potentially block more meaningful moves.

It’s also worth noting that the Mariners had interest in Santana last offseason, reportedly offering a two-year deal before being outbid. At the time, many wondered if the front office missed an opportunity, but with how poorly Santana’s season has gone, it’s clear they dodged a bullet. Bringing him in now would only undo that good fortune.

Seattle doesn’t need to chase nostalgia. They need to stay disciplined, focus on players who can make a tangible impact (and they have already shown a willingness to do that this year), and resist the urge to add another poor-hitting veteran first baseman. Santana may still be a fan favorite, but the Mariners are better off steering clear.