Skip to main content

Mariners fans aren’t ready for the seismic upgrade of Maikel Garcia’s defense

Quantifying Maikel Garcia's improvement for the Mariners at the hot corner.
ByMike Sakuraba
Cleveland Guardians v Kansas City Royals
Cleveland Guardians v Kansas City Royals | Jay Biggerstaff/GettyImages

The Seattle Mariners set out this offseason with a goal to improve the left side of their infield. With the trade for Maikel Garcia, they did just that, but the 26-year-old Venezuelan isn't just going to be an improvement; he'll be a revelation.

Seattle ranked dead last in the MLB this year with a Fielding Run Value of -59: a Statcast statistic that measures a team's defensive worth compared to an average defender. Alright, that all sounds awful, but just awful was it? Using Statcast's metric, the Chicago Cubs were the best defensive team in the league with 72 runs above average: a shocking difference of 131 runs.

Let's take a look at another Statcast metric: Outs Above Average. This is a cumulative measurement that keeps a running total throughout the season of defensive plays made and missed. The Mariners also ranked last in this measure, with a surprisingly similar gap of 130 OAA between them and the Cubs.

President of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto called the team's defensive efforts "atrocious" last year, and was determined to improve it this offseason. At the recent GM meetings, Dipoto went out of his way to point out that, as good as the pitching staff is, it is difficult to win games consistently when giving away outs. He's not wrong: the Mariners' starting rotation posted a FIP of 3.98 compared to an ERA of 4.20. That is a tough gap to overcome for a rotation that is supposed to be the strength of the team.

Well, Dipoto followed through on his word and landed Garcia from the Kansas City Royals. Here's why Garcia may not just be an upgrade for the Mariners, but a glove who can change the trajectory of the team's season.

Maikel Garcia: the Mariner's answer to the revolving door of questionable third basemen

It's been a struggle for the Mariners at third base over the past few seasons. In fact, Garcia is clearly the best option at the hot corner that Seattle has had since franchise legend Kyle Seager.

Since becoming a full-time player in 2023, Garcia has a measurement of 39 OAA in 522 games with the Royals. As a group, the Mariners' third basemen have combined for a score of -4 OAA over that same period. In 2025, the year that Garcia won the Gold Glove Award, he amassed 18 OAA, the second-best defensive season by a third baseman since 2023.

In comparison, the Mariners' third base position has been a sore spot since Seager retired in 2021. Last year, the Mariners traded for utility infielder Brendan Donovan, but an injury-hampered season and notably average arm strength reduced his effectiveness at third base. Before Donovan, fan favorite Eugenio Suárez manned the position. Seattle will always have a soft spot for "Geno," but his defense has certainly been far from impressive, especially in his later years.

Converting either J.P. Crawford or Colt Emerson didn't seem like the ideal answer either. Now, the Mariners have parted ways with Crawford, and as popular as he was, the acquisition of Garcia has softened that blow. And on the bright side, the team is now entering 2027 with Garcia, Emerson, Cole Young, and Josh Naylor around the horn. Not too shabby an infield, now that it's anchored by two Gold Glove winners.

Maybe the more exciting thing for Mariners fans is that Garcia is not just a strong defensive glove. He's averaged a .758 OPS over the past two seasons, hitting 19 home runs and swiping 28 bases. For all that Dipoto has not done to improve the Mariners, credit needs to be given where it is due: he hit it out of the park with the trade for Garcia, and the Mariners enter 2027 as a much better team on both sides of the ball.

Add us as a preferred source on Google