In a span of a year, Logan Gilbert went from being obviously the ace of the Seattle Mariners ace to just nominally so. Even when he made his second straight Opening Day start on March 26, he still lacked a key ingredient that went missing right around when he injured his arm last April: velocity.
That is until Wednesday, anyway. Though it was Rob Refsnyder and the righty bats who once again stole the show as the Mariners completed a sweep of the Athletics, Gilbert went full "Walter" in pitching six scoreless innings. And his fastball? It was humming:
- Average Speed: 96.4 mph
- Max Speed: 98.3 mph
The average tied Gilbert's best mark for the 2026 season so far. The max is his new high for the season, and it was one of two heaters he threw over 98 mph. He threw exactly that many 98 mph fastballs all year in 2025, and only once after he came back from the flexor strain in his right arm.
“I've been trying to get there, honestly, and felt like I've been throwing the ball well at times,” Gilbert said after the game, via Daniel Kramer of MLB.com. “I just didn't quite have that velo. But to see it today, honestly, like, answered prayers.”
Logan Gilbert finally returning to form could answer a major question hanging over Mariners
It's OK to still be a little trepidatious about Gilbert. He entered yesterday's start with a 4.04 ERA, after all, and other aspects are rocky as well. He hasn't kicked last year's elevated home run rate, for one. For two, his strikeout percentage is down from an elite 32.3 to a merely above-average 25.0.
But if nothing else, the velocity he showed on Wednesday was a flashback to 2024.
Logan Gilbert, 98mph Fastball (home plate view) pic.twitter.com/Z7YMGMvdWI
— Rob Friedman (@PitchingNinja) May 27, 2026
Remember the heater he had that year? Of course you do. It sat at 96.6 mph and got as high as 100.5 mph, and he could use it to just plain blow hitters away. They hit just .205 against it, making it a vital component of a campaign that saw him lead MLB in innings and WHIP.
Coming off a season like that, the Cy Young buzz for 2025 was inevitable. Yet the arm injury from last year still looks like a demarcation point. In his last 31 starts before it happened, he had a 3.18 ERA and a 0.86 WHIP. In 31 starts since it happened, he has a 3.73 ERA and a 1.11 WHIP. That's a transition from great to merely good.
Still, there's no harm in indulging in a little hope that Gilbert found something again on Wednesday. Because if so, it could have huge ramifications for a starting rotation that doesn't just have a piggyback problem. There's also the "no clear Game 1 starter" problem.
With all respect to George Kirby, Bryan Woo and Emerson Hancock, if the Gilbert of 2024 does indeed make a comeback, he's about to be the right answer to that question.
