After eight seasons in Seattle, J.P. Crawford's time with the Mariners has come to an end. The team's longest-tenured player is officially a free agent, leaving the Pacific Northwest and opening the door to a new chapter somewhere else. While many Mariners fans are disappointed to see him go, others recognize that a change might be the best option for both sides. Before Crawford finds his next team, there's plenty worth knowing about what he brings to the table, both the good and the bad.
If there's one thing to know about J.P. Crawford, it's that he loves Seattle. He's never been one to shy away from expressing his love for the city, the organization, or the fans who have supported him since day one. That connection made him a beloved player in the clubhouse, and throughout the Pacific Northwest. Now that he is entering free agency, it's time to look beyond his emotional ties to the city and consider what another team might get if they decide to take a chance on Crawford.
A few of the many upsides to J.P. Crawford that Mariners fans got to know
Known for his heart and his personality, Crawford has earned a reputation as one of the more well-liked players in Seattle. He had been with the organization longer than anyone else on the roster, and his experience made him an important part of the team's identity.
His value, however, extends beyond just being a veteran. Crawford was part of the organization through all the highs and lows of recent years. His familiarity with the team, the city, the fanbase, and the expectations that come with playing in Seattle turned him into a glue guy. Both teammates and fans appreciated him and relied on him, and that's not really something that can be measured with stats.
His willingness to put his team's needs ahead of his own is another example of the kind of player Crawford is. After spending many seasons as Seattle's shortstop, he was willing to move over to third base to make room for top prospect Colt Emerson. That kind of flexibility and team-first mentality make a veteran more valuable than what just his numbers might show.
Another one of Crawford's strengths is his approach at the plate. While he may not be the most productive hitter in the lineup, he still knows how to work an at-bat and make pitcher earn the out. In 2026, he drew 64 walks against 97 strikeouts, finishing the season with a .335 on-base percentage despite hitting just .221. He also showed he still knows how to handle four-seam fastballs, batting .266 with .422 slugging percentage against them in 2026. For a veteran hitter, that's definitely an upside.
The concerns surrounding J.P. Crawford as he departs Seattle
Unfortunately, in recent years Crawford's offensive production hasn't exactly been consistent. After a solid 2023 in which he hit .266/.380/.438 with 19 home runs, his numbers dropped in 2024. He came back a little bit in 2025, hitting .265 with a .352 on-base percentage, but struggled again this season. He finished 2026 batting .221/.335/.352 with 14 home runs and 40 RBIs. While Crawford doesn't offer a ton of upside at the plate, he does still has the ability to work counts, something he has long been known for. But if a team is in need of a huge offensive upgrade, Crawford might not be the right fit.
Defensively, his range and arm strength have also become concerns, making it difficult for him to handle the demands of playing shortstop all season long. If a team is looking for a infield boost, Crawford likely isn't the option there either.
We didn’t get this JP Crawford for nearly long enough, but for 2-3 years, he was one of the best shortstops I’ve ever seen pic.twitter.com/6NeReIUW1Q
— Mariner Muse (@MarinerMuse) November 11, 2026
Another question mark is his health. Crawford has dealt with injuries in two of the last three seasons, including three separate stints on the injured list just in 2026. That's difficult to ignore for any potentially interested team. A full offseason could help him recover, but theres no guarantee those issues won't return.
Of course, there's something to be said about how much of Crawford's personality and identity have become intertwined with Seattle. He spent eight season growing and changing with the organization, building relationships with teammates and fans, and becoming one of the most recognizable faces on the Mariners. It's fair to wonder if he will have the same presence in a different uniform, away from the city he's called home for so long.
But, something tells me Crawford will be just fine. While he might not be the offensive or defensive force that he once was, his presence could be exactly what a team looking for veteran leadership and reliable infield depth needs. Plus, his personality, work ethic, and willingness to put his teammates first aren't qualities that simply disappear when a player changes teams. Seattle may have brought out a special side to Crawford, but who's to say another team won't do the same?
