The MLB awards season isn't over yet. The 2026 winners for the Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger awards, presented by FanSided, are due to be announced on Tuesday. Randy Arozarena is the Seattle Mariners' lone finalist, and he's as sure a winner as there is in the American League.
The Silver Sluggers are voted on by MLB managers and coaches, who are meant to combine their own impressions of hitters with knowledge of statistics like OBP, OPS, OPS+, home runs, hits, RBI and batting average. There are times when this process can result in "eye of the beholder" judgments that foster disagreement and debate.
But in the case of Arozarena? Nah. Among all American League hitters, he was top-10 in batting average, on-base percentage and slugging percentage. He was fourth overall with a 148 OPS+, which was also the high mark among AL outfielders.
Randy Arozarena truly did it all for the 2026 Mariners in his quest to win his 1st Silver Slugger
Some things are hard to describe to anyone who didn't watch the 2026 Mariners on an everyday basis. Like, for example, just how antithetical to the team Arozarena was throughout the year. The team was so bad that it eventually caused Angie Mentink to have an on-air breakdown. But Arozarena was good. Weekly. Monthly. Daily. Hourly. Just plain good.
There wasn't a single month this year in which Arozarena's wRC+ went below 128. That's the same wRC+ that Alex Bregman had for the whole year, and he's up for a Silver Slugger at third base in the National League. When a hitter's worst work is the same as a three-time All-Star's baseline, well, that's pretty good.
LEADOFF HOMER ➡️ WALK-OFF HOMER
— MLB (@MLB) August 23, 2026
RANDY AROZARENA WINS IT FOR THE @MARINERS! pic.twitter.com/iCYCRYwo4u
It all speaks to the intentional shift Arozarena made with his approach this year. By his own admission, he used to take at-bats with a "Hit this ball out" mindset. Not anymore in 2026, which was about having a plan putting the ball in play to the right place in the field.
The proof is in the pudding. After batting .238 overall in 2025, Arozarena batted at least .270 against all three pitch types in 2026. And for the first time in his career, he put over 80 balls in play to his pull side and oppo side and had an OPS over 1.000 in both directions.
The 2026 Silver Sluggers will otherwise have Mariners fans waiting until next year
There isn't a whole lot else for Mariners fans to root for, vis-à-vis the big reveal of the Silver Slugger winners on Tuesday. It remains a bummer that Dominic Canzone isn't up for one, but that's life when a guy shares the DH position with Yordan Alvarez and Ben Rice.
Even Arozarena's eventual win will feel bittersweet. Nominally, he'll become the first Mariners left fielder to ever win a Silver Slugger. More practically, the award will go to a free agent and bolster a case for a payday that already feels beyond Seattle's reach.
The thing to do, then, is cross one's fingers for better luck next year. Cal Raleigh and Julio Rodríguez are past Silver Sluggers who might be back in the conversation next year. Canzone could be as well, and don't count out Josh Naylor, Cole Young, Brendan Donovan or Lazaro Montes, the latter of whom could be a 30-homer slugger as a rookie next year.
