Here are the Seattle Mariners Ratings for MLB the Show 23

3 of 4

This is one of my favorite days of the year. I always pre-order MLB the Show each year, as it's worth it to me to get that extra weekend of playtime in before the actual release. I don't dive straight into the game though. Nope, instead, I go and compile all the rankings of the Seattle Mariners. It's fun to see them all in one place, especially for those who are curious about how a team looks, or for those who didn't pre-order the game.

Officially releasing on March 28th, those who pre-ordered were able to get the game on March 23rd at 9PM West Coast time. Usually, you see a bit of server issues the night of, but for the most part the game runs pretty well out of the gate. It's a bit late this year as I ended up being busy, but I still wanted to give out all the Mariners rankings.

It's time to talk about the Mariners ratings in MLB the Show 23

I'm going to go through two different sets of ratings here. You can call them offline and online. Or, as most people likely would be referring to them, Franchise mode and Diamond Dyansty. A quick refresher for those unfamiliar, Franchise is an offline mode where you take over a team (or fantasy draft), where you can either play the games on your own or go GM style and try and build a champion. This is more of the old school mode, and the one that has been around longer.

The other mode is Diamond Dynasty. In this, you are given cards that represent players. As you progress through a multitude of challenges you can earn cards and stubs to better your team. Player ratings are lower here than they are in Franchise, as there are also legends inserted into the game, alongside special player releases and themes, that hold the top-tier within this mode.

In the same mold as last year, here are the MLB the Show 23 Ratings for the Seattle Mariners. We start, with Franchise Mode.

Mariners MLB the Show 23 Franchise Team Rankings

If you saw earlier in the month, the San Diego Studios stream (the game creators) had Robert Flores on to host an early ratings reveal stream, showing a handful of ratings from each team. We get started with once again showing the team's overall rating, and how it breaks down across different categories.

Overall - 11th
Pitching - 11th
Contact - 21st
Power - 9th
Defense - 17th
Speed - 27th

I know that, as a fan, we all think our teams should be rated higher. But come on, there is no way this team is 27th in speed. I know guys like France, Raleigh, and Suarez aren't going to steal bases. However, the team was 16th in steals last year and has only gotten faster. We should see more ABs from Kelenic, Wong is now on the team, and Moore and Haggerty showed that they can easily swipe bags. Plus, some kid named Julio. I'm not saying they should be 10th, but 15th-20th seems right here.

Same with Defense. You know, from the team that had the 3rd fewest errors in baseball and was T-2nd for best fielding percentage. I'm not saying they should be 3rd, but 8-12th seems reasonable. I'll even give them 11th on pitching, because the 5th starter is in question, and the bullpen is less proven than some of the other top ones.

Overall, 11th is probably right. Power at 9th seems right, so does contact at 21st, even though I was expecting 15th-18th. It does seem odd that a team averaging 17 across their ratings would be ranked 11th overall... but Franchise mode has struggled a bit to hold up to reality, which you can see when you dive into the player ratings.

Mariners MLB the Show 23 Franchise Player Rankings

Franchise mode has definitely taken a backseat to Diamond Dynasty. We've seen it across all sports, when microtransactions are involved, that's the mode that makes them money. So, the focus is on MyTeam, Ultimate Team, and Diamond Dynasty. They have put some work into Franchise, but there is still room for a lot more to be added to the mode. It's fun to play, but gets left behind.

So that beings said, let's check out the Franchise Rankings, and then look at who stands out. First, it's the hitters. Note, I did leave some vets out if they were in AAA or AA. There's no reason to talk about Colin Moran (66) being wildly overrated, and the same goes to Justus Sheffield (70).

C - Cal Raleigh - 80
C - Tom Murphy - 75
C - Harry Ford - 66
1B - Ty France - 78
1B - Evan White - 65
2B - Kolten Wong - 74
2B - Dylan Moore - 70
3B - Eugenio Suarez - 80
SS - JP Crawford - 70
OF - Jonatan Clase - 61
OF - Sam Haggerty - 69
OF - Teoscar Hernandez - 87
OF - Cooper Hummel - 65
OF - Jarred Kelenic - 63
OF - Cade Marlowe - 62
OF - AJ Pollock - 80
OF - Julio Rodriguez - 89
OF - Taylor Trammell - 65
DH - Tommy La Stella - 62

MLB the Show 23 nailed these Mariners hitters

Julio at 89 might be a bit low, but I think it's perfect for someone coming off their rookie of the year win. Geno at 80 seems right with the combo of power vs strikeouts. I love that they are ranking Teoscar strong even after coming to the Mariners. He's a monster at the plate, and should be a lot of fun to play with in the game. Ty France might seem low at first, but he can't stay healthy so that seems about right.

MLB the Show 23 struck out on these Mariners hitters

Kolten Wong is better than a 74. He can give you a strong batting average, better than average defense, and has mid teen power and speed. Are you telling me a good glove and a .265 BA with 15 HR and 15 SB is only a 74? No, that's wrong. Then, what in the world is going on with AJ Pollock? In what world is he better than Ty France? He isn't in the same stratosphere as Big Dumper or Geno.

A lot of the time, it seems like they look at vets who have had a good career and just give them a good ranking. Pollock could be a good platoon guy this season, and that's what he should be in the game. Someone with good stats against lefties, can't hit righties that well, and sits around 73.

Now that we've gone through the hitters, it's on to the pitchers to see what they have for rankings.

SP - Luis Castillo - 88
SP - Robbie Ray - 80
SP - Logan Gilbert - 81
SP - George Kirby - 82
SP - Marco Gonzales - 70
SP - Chris Flexen - 64
SP - Bryce Miller - 58
SP - Emerson Hancock - 68
RP - Prelander Berroa - 64
RP - Matt Brash - 72
RP - Isaiah Campbell - 67
RP - Diego Castillo - 72
RP - Matt Festa - 62
RP - Trevor Gott - 62
RP - Andres Munoz - 86
RP - Penn Murfee - 76
RP - Paul Sewald - 80
RP - Justin Topa - 65
RP - Juan Then - 61

MLB the Show 23 nailed these Mariners pitchers

I really enjoy seeing Andres Munoz get some love. 86, with that nasty slider and big-time heat, is a great rating. Sewald is an 80, and is one of those guys whose stuff doesn't seem like it should make him great, which is why he slots a handful of points lower than Munoz. He's still going to be effective in the game because of his control and movement.

Luis Castillo seems spot on at 88. A great pitcher, not yet an Ace until he can show an ability to both go 185+ innings, hit that 3ish ERA, and strike out 200+. He has all of those in his tank, he just needs to combine them.

MLB the Show 23 struck out on these Mariners pitchers

I don't think I agree with Ray, Gilbert, and Kirby. Kirby should be lower, around a 77-78, but have that A potential so he continues to grow. You can't tell me that he is better than Gilbert, after Logan had that 3.2 ERA last year and threw 185 IP. Logan at 81 or so is probably right, but if Kirby is an 82, Gilbert should be an 85. Then there is Ray. With his K ability, that should bump him up. Also, it seems like his Cy Young from 2021 is completely forgotten about. Not that it's up to me, but Ray at 84, Gilbert at 82, and Kirby at 78 would've made more sense.

The hate on Chris Flexen is real. A 64 is just dumb, especially when Marco is a 70. The worst, and I mean THE WORST rating on the pitching staff is Bryce Miller. He's a top 100 prospect, and sits at 58... a full 10 points below Emerson Hancock and 8 points below Taylor Dollard. That's just lazy. RidinRosters did get officially hired on by MLB The Show, so minor league ratings should be way better going forward, and I would expect the first minor league roster update to have Miller jump to around a 64 or 65.

Mariners MLB the Show 23 Diamond Dynasty Player Rankings

I guess I'm part of the reason that Franchise has fallen behind. I enjoy Diamond Dynasty more than any other mode in the game. Between all the challenges and the joy I get from building a team, it's where I spend most of my time. I also enjoy collecting all the cards. Which is getting a lot harder to do with the Mariners as they get better. Especially with a couple of cards pushing diamond status. Let's get to the Mariners Diamond Dynasty Rankings.

C - Cal Raleigh - 79
C - Tom Murphy - 74
1B - Ty France - 78
1B - Evan White - 65
2B - Kolten Wong - 75
2B - Dylan Moore - 71
3B - Eugenio Suarez - 75
SS - JP Crawford - 71
OF - Jonatan Clase - 64
OF - Sam Haggerty - 70
OF - Teoscar Hernandez - 82
OF - Cooper Hummel - 67
OF - Jarred Kelenic - 65
OF - Cade Marlowe - 64
OF - AJ Pollock - 79
OF - Julio Rodriguez - 85
OF - Taylor Trammell - 64
OF - Jonatan Clase - 64
DH - Tommy La Stella - 65
SP - Luis Castillo - 82
SP - Robbie Ray - 81
SP - Logan Gilbert - 78
SP - George Kirby - 78
SP - Marco Gonzales - 68
SP - Chris Flexen - 63
RP - Prelander Berroa - 65
RP - Matt Brash - 69
RP - Isaiah Campbell - 67
RP - Diego Castillo - 74
RP - Chris Clarke - 63
RP - Matt Festa - 66
RP - Trevor Gott - 72
RP - Easton McGee - 54
RP - Andres Munoz - 84
RP - Penn Murfee - 75
RP - Taylor Saucedo - 52
RP - Paul Sewald - 80
RP - Gabe Speier - 54
RP - Justin Topa - 66
RP - Juan Then - 61
RP - Brennan Bernardino - 58

There are less rankings here than you would see in Franchise. These are only the MLB ready players, and you won't see the prospects. They may come later as part of a prospect program, but there is nothing there now.

I'm doing this a bit different than the Franchise breakdown... but still similar, and you'll see why.

These MLB the Show Mariners are a bargain in Diamond Dynasty

Logan Gilbert (78) is prime for a big season, and should jump to a gold soon. Especially if he dominates April like he did in 2022. If you grab a handful of his cards, you should be able to sell them in May for a nice profit. Ty France (78) is a gold player if he can be healthy. If that happens, there is no way they keep a 300+ hitter on a 20-25 homer pace as a silver card.

Keep an eye on Kelenic (65) too. If you really think he will succeed this year, he could jump to a silver quickly with his combination of speed and power. I'd go after Diego Castillo (74) as well. A single-point increase will bump him to silver, instantly increasing his value. Chris Flexen (63) just seems lazy. Anyone that's watched him knows he is better than that, and he should jump to the 70s if he stays healthy.

These MLB the Show Mariners cost a lot more than they should in Diamond Dynasty

Don't bet on AJ Pollock (79) to stay that high. There's no way he stays a 79 unless he is hitting 280 with a nice power surge or some leftover speed from his youth.

I love Cal Raleigh (79), but his ranking worries me. A slow start, a struggle with either power or average, and he is going to drop a few points. He's the 11th ranked catcher, so they've been pretty easygoing with catcher rankings (10 gold and above), but I still wouldn't invest a ton in Raleigh

Now, get out there and play some MLB the Show 23! It's a wonderful game with a ton of depth, and where you can find me for the next 3-4 months. If you wanna play, hit me up on Twitter or online at DeionValkyre. Go Mariners!

Home / Mariners News