| ESPN | Baseball Prospectus | MinorLeagueBall | |
| Keith Law | Kevin Goldstein | John Sickles | |
| 1 | Dustin Ackley | Michael Pineda | Michael Pineda |
| 2 | Michael Pineda | Dustin Ackley | Dustin Ackley |
| 3 | Nick Franklin | Nick Franklin | Nick Franklin |
| 4 | James Jones | Guillermo Pimentel | Taijuan Walker |
| 5 | Taijuan Walker | Taijuan Walker | Mauricio Robles |
| 6 | Mauricio Robles | Mauricio Robles | Alex Liddi |
| 7 | Alex Liddi | Dan Cortes | Guillermo Pimentel |
| 8 | Marcus Littlewood | Kyle Seager | Johermyn Chavez |
| 9 | Johermyn Chavez | Blake Beavan | Kyle Seager |
| 10 | Stephen Pryor | Johermyn Chavez | James Jones |
| 11 | Alex Liddi | Dan Cortes | |
| 12 | Ramon Morla | Marcus Littlewood | |
| 13 | Maikel Cleto* | Ramon Morla | |
| 14 | Marcus Littlewood | Nate Tenbrink | |
| 15 | Josh Lueke | Ji-Man Choi | |
| 16 | Greg Halman | Blake Beavan | |
| 17 | Ji-Man Choi | Vince Catricala | |
| 18 | James Jones | Esteilon Peguero | |
| 19 | Carlos Peguero | Stephen Pryor | |
| 20 | Jordan Shipers | Josh Lueke |
*signifies the player has since been traded.
| Baseball America | Fangraphs | Hardball Times | |
| Conor Glassey | Marc Hulet | Matt Hagen | |
| 1 | Dustin Ackley | Michael Pineda | Michael Pineda |
| 2 | Michael Pineda | Dustin Ackley | Nick Franklin |
| 3 | Nick Franklin | Nick Franklin | Dustin Ackley |
| 4 | Taijuan Walker | Taijuan Walker | Carlos Triunfel |
| 5 | Guillermo Pimentel | Guillermo Pimentel | Johermyn Chavez |
| 6 | Mauricio Robles | Mauricio Robles | Mauricio Robles |
| 7 | Johermyn Chavez | Johermyn Chavez | Rich Poythress |
| 8 | Marcus Littlewood | Kyle Seager | James Jones |
| 9 | Kyle Seager | Dan Cortes | Blake Beavan |
| 10 | Dan Cortes | Blake Beavan | Alex Liddi |
Loading ...
Call to the Pen
FanSided
Chicken Friars
Halo Hangout
Kings of Kauffman
Marlin Maniac
Nolan Writin'
Swingin' A's
