I made a comment the other night on twitter that there wasn’t much room for an upgrade on this team. That’s kind of a stupid thing to say. I mean of course there are room for upgrades to make on the team. I’d dare say you could most likely upgrade every position but two on this roster.
But, I made the comment more out of the respect for where we are as an organization and with the encompassing youth that are not only near to contributing but many of them with the team now.
I’ve seen many comments far and wide across different blogs that talk about upgrades and they talk about prospects and I get the feeling that sometimes people make the mistake of thinking that someone youthful, without an ESPN or Baseball America prospect stamp can’t make an impact on a team.
Sure, you’d want an Eric Hosmer, a Desmond Jennings and most certainly a Mike Trout type prospect within your organization ready to jump start an offense like the Mariners. Someone who could make a super-star/all-star type impact on your team. The fact of the matter is however that 99% of minor leaguers are not those players.
Look at the top-5 position players in WAR right now
Pedroia during his time was an average prospect, but the year of his rookie breakout (2007) Baseball America didn’t even rank him in their top-100.He was rated as high as #77 overall in 2006 but dropped off due to some injuries.
Joey Bats, prior to being passed around like a cheap party trick, was highest pegged as the 5th best prospect in the Pirates system and never made it on to a top-100 list. Baseball America rated Paul Maholm and Tom Gorzelanny as better potential prospects than him.
Troy Tulowitzki is a bit of a lone wolf on this list as he was rated #25 and then #15 prior to this ascension to stardom. Basically we all knew he was going to be good… pretty much before he got there.
Ben Zobrist didn’t even make an organizations top-10 prospect list. The biggest shout out he got was in 2005 when Baseball America said he had the Best Strike-Zone Discipline in the organization. Outside of that he got little to no prospect love.
Victorino is one of the rule-V draftee success stories that Philly picked up out of the Dodgers organization. Never on much of anyone’s radar but he turned out to be a league average hitter with great defense in center. Then this year he has really broken out and is currently posting a wOBA of .407 and is worth +7.3 runs according to defensive metrics.
The point of this is that you don’t know what guys are going to turn into. That’s not to say that you never trade prospects. There are always situations where you have to compare what is right for your organization going forward.
I don’t like the idea of upgrading the outfield at this time because whether you want to believe it or not Mike Carp is at the very least a big league hitter and he may even be better than that. He may not be a very good fielder and in reality he’s really average at best, but his defense isn’t at a point that it will kill you.
Casper Wells has consistently shown he can hit at every level and is right now an above-average hitter. How long does that last? I’m not sure. But he’s had a consistently high BABIP through our his minor league career so maybe he can keep it up. What’s the point of upgrading him if … well you’re not sure what you have to begin with.
Franklin Gutierrez is locked into a team friendly contract and if he can get back to hitting league average or even slightly below, stay healthy and regain form the guy can easily be one of the best Center Fielders in the game and assuredly in the top-5.
Not to mention all the spare parts you have in Halman, Peguero, Saunders and the newest addition of Trayvon Robinson.
Say what you want, and I certainly realize that each of them have their weaknesses, but each has at least 1 +tool and really outside of Peguero each of them have multiple plus tools. Oh, and then we still have Ichiro to figure out what to do with over the next year.
Obviously we can tell that Heyward is the better hitter and despite Wells early accomplishments there are some signs that he may not continue to be an above average hitter. The rose colored glasses aren’t that thick. But it’s still possible he’s a better than average player.
Harrison note: Excuse me for just one moment, I’m sure you’re reading this thinking “Where did anyone suggest we trade for Jason Heyward? Is he really available?” Living in the south, specifically about 100 miles out of Atlanta, I get all the Braves games and talk radio (when it isn’t dominated by SEC talk… *vomits*) and they are really disatistfied with him. So, no. No one is talking about him specifically at this point. This is just an example of an above average or a said desirable player becoming available. Every time you see Jason Heyward from this point forward just insert into your mind the outfielder you find most desirable. Saying desirable that many times makes feel kind of creepy… anyways… returning you back to your regularly scheduled post.
Don’t get me wrong you offer me one of Heyward, Wells or Robinson for free, I’m going to take Heyward every time. But, the problem is it’s not free and we would still have to give
something too much up to get Heyward. Is it worth 2 or 3 top prospect in order to upgrade a position that we aren’t sure is a weakness on this team anymore?
If you are going to give up a Taijuan Walker or even a James Paxton wouldn’t you rather upgrade a position with more uncertainty. That’s even assuming that you think that the organizational pitching is strong enough at this point to flip one of the better lefties in the upper minors or perhaps the best 18-year-old pitchers in the minors.
I get that we have depth for the first time in years and I’m not opposed to spending from it. That’s only logical as we need to get better. But, acquiring talent to upgrade positions rather than taking to time to find out what you have is straight up Bavasism (kind of like communism but worse… at least for teams that like prospects).
Upgrading for the sake of upgrading isn’t always the smartest move. Certainly you always want to get better. We saw the Red Sox look at possibly acquiring Carlos Beltran from the Mets prior to the Giants locking him down. Sure, they have one of the rookie of the year candidates out there now, but Beltran was still an upgrade to Reddick and the Red Sox certainly explored the option and weighed it.
We aren’t there yet. This Mariners team is just not to the point where we can upgrade average to slightly above average players.
I mean if you want to dream get out and get a guy like Geovany Soto or if you really wanted to make things up go after a David Wright or a Ryan Zimmerman.Those guys both have multiple years left on their contracts. Heck if you’re going to get high, sell the farm and go all in on Evan Longoria.
Anyways… *sigh* …. /rant
I like Mike Carp and Casper Wells. I don’t see them as the corner stores of the future or anything like that. But every team needs building blocks and sometimes those blocks turn out to hold more weight than we thought were possible and yet others crumble. I see them as good ball players and useful pieces for this team going forward. There is time to figure out what they are.
Keep Carp and Wells a long with the few other pieces we have and who knows what comes out next year.
I want a .500 team next year. I EXPECT a .500 team next year. So don’t think this is a “let’s try an experiment and if it fails we can always try again next year.” No, I don’t have that mentality at all. This year was suppose to be interesting. This year was suppose to have it’s fun moments and you know, it has. It has been everything I thought it would be and even a little more. Next year we grow up a bit more as a team and we have higher expectations as a fan base.
With Kyle Seager and Alex Liddi both competing for third base and some really interesting prospects in the out field I don’t see the need to upgrade a lot of pieces. I’d rather see it all play itself out (to an extent).
That said I don’t want to watch Olivo next year that would be a plus and I personally have a plan for that too and his name is Ryan Hanigan. But, I’ll have an off-season plan that I’ll put out and that I’m already complying. (Arm Chair GM, not just Keith’s job).
I don’t see the immediate need to throw away our guys for “big names” just yet. I’m pretty content with how things are coming a long right now. If anything with the extra cash I’d sign a reliever or two. But again, those specific crazy thoughts will have to wait for late October. Until then let’s just enjoy watching teams leave Safeco knowing they lost to the “Mariners”.
I can just hear Terry Francona scream obscenities about losing to the #$@#$@! Mariners. This will help me sleep a little better tonight that and my boss is a Red Sox fan and I’ll really get to gloat tomorrow at work.
Tonight I go to bed with the potential thought that our outfield situation may not be as hopeless as what it was in June. I’m very happy we have Casper Wells and Mike Carp…