Trade Thoughts: Robinson and Chiang

Wow, what a mess. First Travyon Robinson is going to Boston then he’s headed to Seattle then Boston and now it’s looking all worked out. With Jack Zduriencik saying that Robinson is headed to Seattle a long with Chih Hsien Chiang of Boston.

I got the privilege of watching Robinson last year while he was with the Chattanooga Lookouts and came away impressed. Solid swing on both sides of the plate and was surprisingly ok in center field for his size. He had good routes, excellent jumps and his speed was slightly better than average.

I don’t think the power is real. Not in the 20+ home run sense. Maybe some of the other guys around town have a better read on that than me. But he’s playing in Albuquerque basically the AAA version of High Desert. While, I wouldn’t say that he doesn’t have power it’s not a great amount.

The plus side of Robinson’s offensive game is that he hits the ball hard. The guy is an absolute line drive machine not to mention he has a solid approach to the plate. He draws an above-average amount of walks and while he may not have “enough” power to be considered a good corner out fielder, he’s still an above average hitter.

The down side of Robinson’s game is that he strike outs. A lot. Part of it’s that he just swings and misses a lot and while that’s generally a bad thing. It’s also that he works a lot of counts and sometimes just isn’t able to make contact to bail himself out of bad counts.

Regardless, I like Robinson a lot and he’s easily a top-10 prospect in our system.

Chiang, I like nearly equally so.

Chih Hsien Chiang has made some changes this year and has really come out on top because of it. He’s been hitting the ball extremely hard and though I have seen only seen little snippets there are a lot of positive things written about his left handed swing.

If Chiang turns out to have real power, and I’m not entirely sure on that but if, he could be the real piece. His bat isn’t elite by any stretch of the imagination but he’s got some exciting attributes.

The downside to his offensive game is simply he doesn’t walk. He doesn’t work a lot of counts and because of that he isn’t going to have a high OBP. Part of his recent success is a high BABIP, but it’s been slightly sustainable due to the fact the he’s been driving the ball so well. When he slumps, and it’s going to happen, I have a suspicion it’s going to be pretty rough.

Defensively, he’s a projected as average defensive corner out fielder with an above average arm. I’ve heard a verity of reports on his range so until I start hearing consistent positive reports he’s merely average in my mind. I think that’s part of the game that in my mind falls short in comparison to Robinson.

Neither prospects are elite. But both are very good pieces to have around and with the struggles that have been endured by a lot of the out fielders within this organization it’s nice to have them around.

I really, really like this deal. It’s sad to see Bedard depart, but they got sweet deal.

Next Mariners Game View full schedule »
Saturday, Aug 2323 Aug1:35at Boston Red SoxBuy Tickets

Tags: Chih-Hsien Chiang Erik Bedard Trayvon Robinson

  • DeniseMoorefield

    Why were the dodgers in this trade? I feel like they gave up the most and got the least.

  • Harrison_Crow

    There is no doubt that a lot of people around baseball feel that way. The word is that Ned Colletti really likes prospect they got from Boston’s Tim Federowicz. He’s certainly interesting though hardly what I’d give up for a Top-100 mlb prospect (Robinson) .

  • maqman

    @Harrison_Crow He was the Dodgers 10th ranked prospect. What the owner and GM are doing to that great team is obscene. Maybe this will help calm the Buy Big Bats crowd. If not what Saunders is doing lately might. Wouldn’t it be something if he finally gets it?

  • Harrison_Crow

    Saunders is showing opposite field power and is walking like a mad man. If he’s figured it out great… but I still would like to keep him down there until September. Just my take.

  • alex.carson

    Mighty big emphasis on if. I’ve fallen for Saunders’ zany tricks before. Not again, I tell you!

  • DeniseMoorefield

    @Harrison_CrowWould you believe it if Saunders was good in Sept? I get a little leary about Sept numbers because of the expanded rosters and young pitchers.

  • Keith_12thMR

    @DeniseMoorefield@Harrison_Crow I’ve got to agree with Denise here. .397 BA from Jeremy Reed was just one example.

    As for Saunders, be careful of his recent numbers. The other night Tacoma faces 2 separate outfielders on the mound in the same game. The recent pitching they’ve face has been atrocious.

    He needs to put up numbers for a couple months before we should start to take notice again.

  • Keith_12thMR

    @DeniseMoorefield Talked with someone who follows the Dodgers, and it was an “organizational depth” decision. With Kemp and Ethier entrenched in the outfield, Robinson was redundant. The belief was that he was ready for a major league call-up, but there was no place to put him, so they flipped him for a catcher they coveted and a couple lesser players.

    Still, You’d think they could have received more for him. I think everyone is a little confused.

  • alex.carson

    @DeniseMoorefield Hey, progress is progress. I’m not real big on reducing positive performances from players who are struggling and need to improve. I tend to believe that, as a person and not just a statline, anything that helps their confidence can only help.

  • alex.carson

    @MarinerMyers@DeniseMoorefield I’d can see their thinking there. Though, I still wonder why they didn’t consider cashing in on Kemp’s big season considering their financial situation. But that org is such a mess right now that it’s likely a fool’s errand to try and figure out what they’re thinking.