Compare and Decide

Who was the more successful major leaguer here? Both are still playing so obviously it’s not completely settle but there is a substantial bit of ground that needs to be made by one of these to catch the other. If you wouldn’t mind let me know in the comments who you voted for and why…

Player X

Age	Lev	PA	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB
18	A-	228	24	53	13	3	7	39	2	7	27	74	.270	.361	.474	.836	93
19	A	416	48	86	10	8	4	39	22	7	48	103	.240	.329	.345	.674	124
20	A+-AA	567	99	144	26	6	15	84	29	11	67	136	.298	.390	.470	.860	227
20	A+	507	91	129	25	4	14	77	27	10	60	116	.299	.392	.473	.866	204
20	AA	60	8	15	1	2	1	7	2	1	7	20	.288	.373	.442	.815	23
21	AA-AAA	394	58	95	22	4	11	46	12	8	39	96	.277	.357	.461	.817	158
21	AA	289	46	72	18	3	8	30	11	6	30	66	.290	.375	.484	.858	120
21	AAA	105	12	23	4	1	3	16	1	2	9	30	.242	.308	.400	.708	38
22	AAA	282	58	77	15	2	13	32	6	3	25	48	.310	.378	.544	.922	135
23	AAA	93	6	16	1	0	0	5	4	0	11	17	.200	.293	.213	.506	17
6 Seasons		1980	293	471	87	23	50	245	75	36	217	474	.276	.361	.441	.802	754
AAA (3 seasons)	AAA	480	76	116	20	3	16	53	11	5	45	95	.274	.346	.449	.795	190
AA (2 seasons)	AA	349	54	87	19	5	9	37	13	7	37	86	.290	.374	.477	.851	143
A (1 season)	A	416	48	86	10	8	4	39	22	7	48	103	.240	.329	.345	.674	124
A- (1 season)	A-	228	24	53	13	3	7	39	2	7	27	74	.270	.361	.474	.836	93
A+ (1 season)	A+	507	91	129	25	4	14	77	27	10	60	116	.299	.392	.473	.866	204

Player Y

Age	Lev	PA	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	TB
20	Rk	131	25	37	8	2	1	16	1	2	9	18	.308	.366	.433	.800	52
21	A-A-	341	42	81	14	2	5	36	0	5	45	54	.278	.374	.392	.765	114
21	A-	156	16	38	5	2	0	15	0	3	21	23	.284	.378	.351	.729	47
21	A	185	26	43	9	0	5	21	0	2	24	31	.274	.370	.427	.796	67
22	A	363	55	102	30	3	7	59	10	5	32	37	.312	.375	.486	.861	159
23	A+	414	59	120	23	9	20	108	4	3	41	49	.332	.395	.612	1.007	221
24	AAA-AA	541	71	143	28	4	12	60	10	9	52	63	.297	.364	.447	.811	215
24	AA	85	12	28	8	1	1	13	3	2	8	7	.368	.424	.539	.963	41
24	AAA	456	59	115	20	3	11	47	7	7	44	56	.284	.353	.430	.783	174
25	AAA	478	84	133	30	5	15	84	7	5	32	75	.304	.349	.498	.847	218
26	AAA	216	24	41	8	1	6	25	1	1	24	47	.216	.301	.363	.664	69
12 Seasons		2614	376	688	149	26	71	407	34	30	242	372	.295	.360	.473	.833	1102
AAA (8 seasons)	AAA	1277	182	320	66	9	37	175	16	13	106	206	.278	.337	.447	.784	515
A (2 seasons)	A	548	81	145	39	3	12	80	10	7	56	68	.300	.373	.467	.840	226
AA (2 seasons)	AA	88	13	28	8	1	1	13	3	2	9	8	.359	.420	.526	.946	41
Rk (1 season)	Rk	131	25	37	8	2	1	16	1	2	9	18	.308	.366	.433	.800	52
A- (1 season)	A-	156	16	38	5	2	0	15	0	3	21	23	.284	.378	.351	.729	47
A+ (1 season)	A+	414	59	120	23	9	20	108	4	3	41	49	.332	.395	.612	1.007	221

Who was the more successful player?

Player X (53%, 23 Votes)
Player Y (47%, 20 Votes)

Total Voters: 43

Loading ...

Keith Myers

As usual I’m the loan dissenting opinion. It would be easy to pick player X based on age and consistent >.800 OPS. My problem with player X is his K rate. A guy who swing and misses that often isn’t as likely to have success at the big league level.
Lauren

I picked player X because comparing the two, player Y has double the experience as X but X is very close or even surpassing a lot of Y’s numbers in half the time.
http://www.sodomojo.com Brett Miller

Player X. Comparable success, younger.
raj

Saunders X?
Wilson Y?