by Taylor 236w ago
Tags: Casey Kotchman Mariners Mike Carp
Image too big.
Also, the Fans projections for Carp are a little ridiculous.
Agree with Jon on the fan projections. .370 OBP, .800 OPS? Maybe at some point in his career, but not in 2010. Also, you know, ~10-15 run difference in defense.
Jon, the point of this post was that though the two are very similar offensively, Kotchman’s defense adds a significant amount of value to the M’s. I would have thought you would get this.
Oh I wasn’t saying that with regards to the post.. more of an aside. I definitely get what you’re trying to say. Me, a few days ago:
“Isn’t Mike Carp basically Kotchman without the defense?
Answer: that’s exactly what he is. And it seems like a reasonable reaction at first, but really, if you have two identical hitters, one led baseball in 1B UZR last season and the other is a poor defender, who would you prefer? “
Admittedly, I probably should have said this in the body of the post. But hey, it’s an exercise in implications!
Pick your favorite teams, topics and players and get content right in your inbox.
© 2014 Fansided, LLC. All rights reserved.